What The Reviewers Say

Positive

Based on 7 reviews

Salka Valka

Halldor Laxness, trans. by Philip Roughton

What The Reviewers Say

Positive

Based on 7 reviews

Salka Valka

Halldor Laxness, trans. by Philip Roughton

Rave
Brad Leithauser,
Wall Street Journal
A second translation arrives as an affirmation of enduring value and an implicit admission of shortcoming: We didn’t do you justice the first time around.
Positive
Charlie Lee,
Baffler
[Laxness'] first attempt to integrate his sense of socialism’s liberatory promise into a cohesive artistic vision.
Rave
Patricia Schultheis,
The Washington Independent Review of Books
Readers who’ve never heard of this fierce, crude, uncompromising, independent, isolated, enterprising, vulnerable daughter of Iceland’s frigid sea and narrow fjords will meet a character who would be as at home at today’s #MeToo rallies as she was nearly a century ago in the tiny village of Óseyr.
Positive
Jane Smiley,
The Washington Post
Laxness explores Salka’s inner life and the social and economic circumstances of the village as both change over the course of about 20 years. Her story is long and somber, but Laxness is adept at putting in some amusing observations.
Rave
M. A. Orthofer,
Complete Review
Laxness' novel is a rich portrait of this simple -- and not so simple -- girl and woman, a remarkably stable pole -- and, in many ways, a model -- for and in a changing world.
Mixed
Hannah Weber,
Words Without Borders
One gets the sense that Laxness’s view of a feminist socialist heroine may simply, at this point in his career, have been ‘a woman in pants’—or, in other words, a woman taking on the role of a man.
Rave
Publishers Weekly
Resonant.