Rave
Hamilton Cain,
The Star Tribune
Eloquent, discursive.
Positive
Simon Winchester,
The New York Times Book Review
The appearance of yet another enthusiastic and erudite history from Simon Schama is an event always to be welcomed.
Rave
Dominic Green,
The Wall Street Journal
The author, a wide-ranging historian and an engaging television host, reconciles the weight of medical detail with the light-footed pleasures of narrative discovery. His book profiles some of the unsung miracle workers of modern vaccination, and offers a subtle rumination on borders political and biological..
Mixed
Julia M. Klein,
The Boston Globe
Simon Schama’s Foreign Bodies,...subtitle seems to promise a distinguished historian’s sweeping, century-spanning dissection of pandemics, vaccines, and public health. That turns out to be misdirection. Schama is a prodigious researcher and an often eloquent stylist. But readers interested in the sociology or epidemiology of plagues, or the science of vaccines, should look elsewhere.
Rave
Matthew Shipsey,
Irish Times (IRE)
Schama pulls delightfully diverse strands...and ties them into a neat bow.
Positive
Rachel Cunliffe,
The Times (UK)
A sweeping account.
Positive
Mark Honigsbaum,
The Guardian (UK)
Schama...is not the obvious or best qualified person to tell these stories. Nonetheless, he has done a superb job of distilling the secondary literature.
Rave
Jerry Brotton,
The Guardian (UK)
...extraordinary.
Rave
Tony Miksanek,
Booklist
This important and inimitable book is sometimes gloomy and tragic, always cautionary and sage..
Positive
Jay Hancock,
The Washington Independent Review of Books
Foreign Bodies isn’t about the recent pandemic, but the reader soon realizes that once covid ambushed the world in 2020, Fauci, Paul, and others were fated to reprise roles written long ago and acted many times.
Rave
Simon Ings,
The Financial Times (UK)
[An] epic and impassioned history.
Rave
Steven Poole,
The Telegraph (UK)
[A] splendid and often moving work of history.
Positive
The Economist
[A] fascinating story of vaccines’ spread.
Positive
Publishers Weekly
Insightful.
Positive
Kirkus
This is a broad canvas, but Schama, a diligent and experienced historian, keeps the narrative on track, and he has a good eye for illustrative anecdotes. It adds up to a strong story that, in the shadow of the Covid-19 pandemic, speaks to us all. A vivid account of the horror of epidemics and the breakthroughs that can bring them under control..